OneNym.idDiscuss deployment
English

THE BOARDROOM FIREWALL / Chapter 14

Cyber Insurance — What It Does and Doesn't Cover

Cyber insurance can pay for experts, notifications and lost income after an incident, but it prevents nothing and covers less than many leaders assume. This chapter explains how to treat insurance as one useful tool rather than a shield.

This page summarises the chapter. The full text is in the book.

Insurance is one tool, not a shield

Insurance transfers part of the financial cost of an incident to someone else. The trouble starts when leaders treat transfer as a substitute for reducing risk. The book groups incident costs into four kinds: direct costs such as forensics, lawyers and notifications; interruption losses; legal costs and claims; and the costs no policy pays, such as departing customers, exhausted staff, a weakened share price and months of distracted leadership. Insurance helps with many of the first, some of the second and third, and none of the fourth, which is often the largest.

The phrase "we're covered" should prompt three questions: covered for what, up to how much, and under what conditions? Every policy has an overall limit and smaller sub-limits, and a serious ransomware incident can exceed what a mid-size company buys. Good controls make insurance cheaper and more reliable; insurance makes the remaining risk survivable.

What policies typically cover and exclude

Wording is not standardised, but most policies combine first-party cover for the company's own losses, such as incident response costs, business interruption after a waiting period, data restoration and cyber extortion, with third-party cover for liability to others, such as privacy claims, regulatory defence and, where insurable, certain fines. Social engineering fraud is often limited or sold separately.

Exclusions are where surprises live: acts of war and state-backed attacks, failures of outside infrastructure, incidents known before the policy began, upgrades beyond the previous state, losses from unpatched known weaknesses or controls not maintained, and theft of intellectual property. In the book's Meridian Foods example, a five-million headline limit hid a much smaller cap on payment fraud and only narrow cover for outages at a cloud provider. Dependent business interruption, covering a supplier's incident that stops your business, can be the most important clause for a company that runs on a few cloud providers.

Why insurers now demand controls, and why answers are promises

After years of heavy ransomware losses, the market hardened: premiums rose sharply, questionnaires grew, limits shrank and retentions grew. Insurers now ask about the same basics the book recommends throughout: multi-factor authentication, separated and tested backups, endpoint detection and response, patching, staff awareness, privileged account controls and a tested incident response plan. The questionnaire is effectively a free outside check on your fundamentals.

The answers on an application are representations the insurer relies on. If a declared control was missing or not working when the incident happened, the claim can be reduced or denied. The danger is usually optimism rather than dishonesty. Each answer should be confirmed by someone who knows the real state, controls should be verified as operating rather than merely purchased, and "mostly, with a plan" is better than a "yes" that proves false. At Meridian, checking MFA system by system before signing found two exceptions that would have made the form untrue. Starting renewal three or four months early leaves time to fix gaps with real work.

How claims actually play out

A cyber claim is a working relationship that starts in the first hours of an incident. Notify the insurer promptly, typically right after engaging legal counsel; late notification is a common and avoidable cause of disputes. Many policies offer a panel of pre-approved firms, and using others without consent may leave the company paying itself, so preferred firms should be approved at renewal. Major decisions, such as paying a ransom, may require the insurer's prior consent.

Afterwards comes the proof of loss. Finance teams that track incident costs under a separate code from day one find this much easier, especially for business interruption. Disputes usually turn on definitions, exclusions, conditions and the true size of the loss, and a broker who advocates for you can make a real difference.

Reading a policy and the limits of transfer

Leaders need not read every word, but should check the schedule of limits, sub-limits, retention and waiting periods; the definitions, which can quietly narrow cover; the conditions, which the incident response plan should satisfy automatically; the exclusions; and the relationships with the broker, the claims handler and the panel. A large overall limit with a small sub-limit on your most likely loss is, for that risk, a small policy.

Contracts are the other transfer tool, and they interact with insurance: penalties promised to customers may be excluded, and a supplier's liability cap may limit what you recover. Some things cannot be transferred at all, including the regulator's judgement, personal reputation and trust. The renewal is also a yearly outside review; at Meridian, the insurer's external scan found a forgotten remote access portal, which led to regular scanning of the company's own. The roof must hold on its own even if the cheque arrives late or small.

KEY POINTS

Key points

  • Ask which of your top five risk scenarios the policy pays for, and how much after sub-limits and retentions.
  • Have someone who knows the real state verify every security answer on the application before it is signed.
  • Start the renewal three or four months before expiry so weak answers can be fixed with real work.
  • Build the insurer's hotline, panel and consent rules into the incident response plan.
  • Check how the policy treats ransom payments, payment fraud and outages at cloud providers.
  • Review once a year how major customer and supplier contracts fit with the insurance policy.

QUESTIONS

Common questions

What does cyber insurance typically cover?
Most cyber policies combine first-party cover for the company's own losses, such as forensic investigation, legal advice, notifications, business interruption, data restoration and extortion costs, with third-party cover for claims by others whose data was exposed and for regulatory defence. Wording varies widely between insurers, so the specific policy must be checked with a broker and legal advisers.
What does cyber insurance not cover?
Common exclusions include acts of war and certain state-backed attacks, failures of outside infrastructure, incidents known before the policy started, upgrades beyond the previous state, losses from unpatched known weaknesses or controls the company failed to maintain, and stolen intellectual property. No policy pays for lost trust, departing customers or diverted leadership attention, which are often the largest costs.
Can a cyber insurance claim be denied?
Yes. Claims can be disputed, reduced or denied when policy conditions are not met, for example when notification is late, when unapproved firms are used without consent, or when a security control declared on the application was not actually in place or working. Disputes usually turn on definitions, exclusions, conditions and the size of the loss.
Why do cyber insurers ask so many security questions?
After years of heavy ransomware losses, insurers learned that a small set of basic controls prevents a large share of serious losses. They now ask about multi-factor authentication, separated and tested backups, endpoint detection, patching, training and incident response plans. The answers shape whether cover is offered and at what price, and they become promises the insurer relies on.
How much cyber insurance cover does a company need?
The limit should be linked to realistic loss scenarios for your own company rather than to what similar companies buy, because exposure depends on revenue concentration, recovery capability and data holdings. Sub-limits matter as much as the headline figure: a large overall limit with a small sub-limit on the loss you are most likely to suffer is, in practice, a small policy for that risk.
What should we do first when making a cyber insurance claim?
Notify the insurer promptly, usually right after engaging legal counsel, using its breach hotline if it has one. Check whether the policy requires panel firms and whether major decisions need the insurer's consent. From the first day, record incident costs under a separate code so the later proof of loss can be supported with evidence.