What a tabletop exercise is for
A tabletop exercise is a rehearsal held around a table. A facilitator describes an incident unfolding in stages and the people in the room discuss what they would do. Nothing is shut down and no decision is binding. Its value lies less in finding correct answers than in surfacing the questions nobody has answered yet: who may shut down the website, who calls the insurer, where the phone list is if email is down. The exercise is set at the fictional Meridian Foods so no one feels their own systems are on trial, but the facilitator keeps asking how each step would work in your company.
It focuses on leadership decisions, not technical recovery. Participants are asked who decides, on what information, how quickly and with what consequences.
Format and participants
Allow 90 minutes: about an hour for six staged injects and 20 to 30 minutes for the debrief, which should never be skipped. Eight to twelve players is a good size, typically the chief executive, finance, legal, communications, operations, IT and security leads, and two or three directors. A separate facilitator runs the session and a note-taker records decisions and gaps. Bring the real incident response plan, the insurance summary and hotline, and a printed contact list. Ground rules stress that this is a no-fault exercise and that saying you do not know is useful information.
How the scenario unfolds
It begins early on a Tuesday in Meridian's busiest season, when production screens show a ransom message and the warehouse system will not load. Over the following stages the picture grows: the attackers have been inside for at least ten days, they demand payment within 72 hours and claim to have copied data, warehouse backups turn out to have been encrypted too, a journalist asks for comment, and a social media post shows what looks like employee data. Each stage comes with discussion prompts, such as whether to disconnect from the internet and who decides, and what the insurance policy says about ransom payments.
The third stage, where the ransom decision is explored, is the heart of the exercise. The facilitator is told not to let the group settle quickly either way, and to remind players that paying guarantees neither recovery nor deletion of stolen data. The final stage, six days later, reveals that the attackers entered through an IT provider's remote access account without multi-factor authentication.
Debrief and follow-up
The debrief works through four questions: what went well, what surprised us, what gaps we found, and what we will do, by whom and by when. Gaps should be specific enough to act on, and five to ten actions are better than thirty. A short report should follow within a week, and the board should review progress at its next meeting. Many companies repeat a tabletop yearly with a different scenario, and the details can be adapted freely to your own critical systems.
KEY POINTS
Key points
- Run a leadership tabletop exercise at least once a year, rotating the scenario.
- Agree in advance who has authority to declare an incident and disconnect systems.
- Keep the incident response plan and contact list reachable when email and shared drives are down.
- Agree principles for a ransom demand before a crisis, not during one.
- Turn every gap into an action with an owner and a date, and limit the list to five to ten items.
QUESTIONS
Common questions
- What is a cyber tabletop exercise?
- A tabletop exercise is a discussion-based rehearsal in which a facilitator describes a cyber incident in stages and leaders talk through what they would do at each point. Nothing is switched off and no decisions are binding. Its main value is revealing unanswered questions, such as who has authority to disconnect systems, before a real incident forces them.
- How long should a ransomware tabletop exercise take?
- The Boardroom Firewall recommends about 90 minutes: roughly 60 to 70 minutes for six staged scenario updates and 20 to 30 minutes for a debrief. If only an hour is available, shorten the discussion at each stage and keep the debrief to fifteen minutes, but never skip it, because most of the value lies there.
- Who should take part in an executive tabletop exercise?
- Eight to twelve players works well, typically the chief executive, chief financial officer, general counsel or company secretary, head of communications, chief operating officer, head of IT, head of security and two or three board members. A facilitator who is not a player runs the session, and a note-taker records decisions, open questions and gaps.
- What decisions does a board face in a ransomware attack?
- Leaders must decide who declares a major incident, whether to disconnect systems even if it stops customer-facing services, what to tell customers, staff, regulators and the press, and whether to consider paying a ransom. Paying raises legal questions such as sanctions, depends on insurance terms, and guarantees neither recovery nor deletion of stolen data.
- What should happen after a tabletop exercise?
- Each gap found should become a specific action with an owner and a date, ideally five to ten actions focused on the first twenty-four hours of a real incident. Within a week a short report should be circulated, and the board or risk committee should review progress at its next meeting.