OneNym.idDiscuss deployment
English

ASSESSMENT CRITERIA / VERSION 1.0 / 2026-11

AI & Cloud Security Assessment Criteria v1.0

These criteria allow an organization to show its business partners that it is doing everything it reasonably can. OneNym.id publishes in full what it checks during an assessment and what must be met for the AI & Cloud Security Assessment Certificate to be issued. Business partners who receive the Certificate can confirm what it means on this page.

11
areas
40
Required
34
Recommended
17
of them on generative AI

SCOPE

Purpose and scope

These criteria apply to organizations that use cloud services, SaaS, and generative AI in their business (mainly Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, Azure, AWS, Google Cloud, Claude, ChatGPT, and Copilot). The assessment covers configuration, operating rules, records, and organizational arrangements as of the assessment date. Malware analysis of PCs or servers, penetration testing, physical security, and determinations of legal compliance are out of scope.

These criteria are not a certification scheme such as ISO/IEC 27001 (ISMS) or the PrivacyMark; they are assessment criteria defined independently by OneNym.id. When the government's security assessment scheme for supply chains, currently under development, comes into effect, a mapping between that scheme and each item will be added.

The two documents issued

CERTIFICATE

AI & Cloud Security Assessment Certificate

A one-page document for presenting to business partners. It states the grade, scope, expiry date, and the result for each area, with the result for generative AI use shown on a separate line. It does not describe weaknesses in detail.

REPORT

AI & Cloud Security Assessment Report

A report covering every item, held only by the client. It states the result for each item, the basis for that result, and improvement priorities.

RESULTS

Result categories

Each item is either Required or Recommended, and its result is one of the following four. Where there is no evidence, the result is Fail; a verbal explanation alone is never sufficient for a Pass.

Pass
The requirement is met and has been confirmed by evidence
Conditional pass
Part of the requirement is not yet met, but the impact is limited and a time-bound improvement plan has been agreed
Fail
The requirement is not met, or cannot be confirmed for lack of evidence
Not applicable
The relevant service or business process is not used (the reason is stated in the Report)

GRADES

Grades

The Certificate is issued at one of three grades according to scope and level of achievement. Stars are not used, to avoid confusion with the ★ ratings of the government's assessment scheme.

STANDARD

Standard

Cloud, SaaS, and generative AI (the 10 areas other than END)

No Fail on any of the 37 Required items outside END

PLUS

Plus

The Standard scope plus business endpoints (END)

The Standard conditions are met, and there is no Fail on any of the 3 Required END items

ADVANCED

Advanced

Same as Plus

All 40 Required items are Pass (with no Conditional pass), and at least 24 of the 34 Recommended items are Pass

ISSUANCE

Issuance, validity, and revocation

  1. No more than 3 Required items may be a Conditional pass, and the improvements and supporting evidence must be submitted within 90 days of the issue date.
  2. The Certificate is valid for one year from the assessment completion date. It can be renewed by completing a reassessment before it expires.
  3. OneNym.id does not publish the names of companies to which it has issued a Certificate. There is no public list; the client decides to whom it shows its Certificate.
  4. Each Certificate is assigned a non-guessable ID and a verification code. Only a person who enters both on the verification page is shown the company name, grade, expiry date, and status (valid, expired, or revoked).
  5. The Certificate is revoked if conditions remain unresolved after the improvement deadline, if submitted materials prove to be inaccurate, if the Certificate has been altered, or if it is presented as covering more than its stated scope.
  6. If a serious incident affecting the assessed scope comes to light, the client is required to report it, and the relevant areas are re-examined.

How items are verified

Assessments are, in principle, carried out with read-only permissions, and each item is verified with one of the following three types of evidence. Any content organized with the help of AI is checked against the evidence by an assessor before a result is determined.

Configuration
Admin consoles, configuration exports, and output from verification scripts
Records
Policies, registers, procedures, records of training and exercises, and restore test results
Interview
Confirmation of actual practice. An item is rated Pass on interview alone only where no record could exist

CRITERIA

Assessment items

There are 74 items across 11 areas (40 Required, 34 Recommended). Generative AI, with 17 items, is the most heavily weighted area. "ISO ref." gives the numbers of related controls in ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A, provided for reference only as an aid to understanding. It does not indicate conformity with ISO.

GOVGovernance and policy

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
GOV-1 An information security lead has been appointed, and this is known across the organization Required Records · Interview 5.2
GOV-2 An inventory of the cloud services, SaaS, and generative AI used in the business exists, and an administrator is assigned to each Required Records 5.9, 5.23
GOV-3 An information security policy is documented and reviewed at least once a year Required Records 5.1
GOV-5 Rules for remote work and for business use of personal devices are documented and communicated Required Records 6.7

IAMIdentity and access

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
IAM-1 Multi-factor authentication is required for all users Required Configuration 8.5
IAM-2 There are 2 to 5 top-level administrators, and they use dedicated administrator accounts separate from their everyday accounts Required Configuration 8.2
IAM-3 Legacy authentication (basic authentication and connection methods that do not support multi-factor authentication) is disabled Required Configuration 8.5
IAM-4 Accounts of departing employees are disabled within 1 business day of their departure date (checked against recent departures) Required Configuration · Records 5.18
IAM-5 Shared accounts are not used. Where one is unavoidable, its owner, purpose, and multi-factor authentication are managed Required Configuration · Records 5.16
IAM-9 External user (guest) accounts are reviewed at least every six months, and those no longer needed are removed Required Configuration · Records 5.18

DATData sharing and personal information

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
DAT-1 Sharing that allows anyone with the link to open content is disabled or has an expiry date set Required Configuration 5.14
DAT-2 Automatic forwarding of email to external addresses is blocked Required Configuration 5.14
DAT-3 A register records where customer and employee personal information is held and who can access it Required Records 5.12, 5.34

MAILEmail and spoofing protection

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
MAIL-1 SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are configured for the organization's domains, and reports on spoofed email are received Required Configuration 5.14
MAIL-2 Scanning of attachments and links in inbound email is enabled Required Configuration 8.7

AIGenerative AI use

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
AI-1 There is a list of AI tools approved for business use, and a person is designated to approve new tools Required Records 5.23
AI-2 Rules on what information may and may not be entered into AI are documented and communicated Required Records · Interview 5.10
AI-3 Approved tools are covered by contracts or settings that prevent input from being used for training Required Configuration · Records 5.23
AI-4 AI tools are managed through organizational accounts (SSO or an admin console), and access is disabled when an employee leaves. Business use of personal accounts is prohibited Required Configuration · Records 5.16, 5.18
AI-5 Each AI API key has a designated owner and the minimum necessary permissions, is not hard-coded, and is reissued at least once a year Required Configuration · Records 5.17, 8.2
AI-8 Features for sharing AI conversations or projects outside the organization (such as public links) are disabled or require approval Required Configuration 5.14
AI-9 Data sources connected to AI (connectors, MCP servers, plugins) require approval and are managed in an inventory Required Configuration · Records 5.15, 5.23
AI-10 The incident response plan covers AI-related incidents (confidential information entered by mistake, leaked API keys, erroneous actions by agents) Required Records 5.24

APPConnected apps

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
APP-1 The scope within which ordinary users can consent to connected apps is restricted, and all other consents are approved by an administrator Required Configuration 5.15
APP-2 Connected apps with broad permissions are reviewed at least once a year Required Configuration · Records 5.18

ENDEndpoints (Plus and above)

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
END-1 Operating systems and browsers on business endpoints update automatically, and no operating system that is out of support is in use Required Configuration · Records 8.8
END-2 Antivirus or EDR is enabled on all endpoints Required Configuration 8.7
END-3 Storage on laptops and smartphones is encrypted Required Configuration 8.1, 8.24

LOGLogging and detection

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
LOG-1 Audit logs for key services (Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, and cloud activity logs) are enabled Required Configuration 8.15
LOG-2 Audit logs and sign-in records can be accessed for at least 180 days (stored externally where the service's retention period is shorter) Required Configuration 8.15
LOG-3 The recipients of critical security alerts and the people responsible for reviewing them are designated Required Configuration · Interview 8.16

BCKBackup and recovery

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
BCK-1 The scope and method of backup for important data (including data held in SaaS) are defined Required Records · Configuration 8.13
BCK-2 A restore from backup is tested at least once a year, and the results are recorded Required Records 8.13

IRIncident response

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
IR-1 A documented response plan exists that sets out contacts, decision-makers, and procedures for the first 24 hours Required Records 5.24, 5.26
IR-2 Procedures for reporting a personal information breach (preliminary and final reports to Japan's Personal Information Protection Commission (PPC), and notification of affected individuals) are defined Required Records 5.24, 5.31
IR-3 A procedure exists for exporting and preserving logs in the event of an incident, and the responsible staff are able to carry it out Required Records · Interview 5.28
IR-5 External contacts for incidents (lawyers, cyber insurer, forensic investigators, support contacts for services in use, police consultation services, key business partners) are listed Required Records 5.5, 5.6

PPLPeople and training

IDRequirementLevelEvidenceISO ref.
PPL-1 Security training (including phishing and AI usage rules) is given to all staff at least once a year, and attendance is recorded Required Records 6.3
PPL-2 A point of contact for reporting suspicious email or events is designated and communicated Required Records · Interview 6.8
PPL-5 Confidentiality undertakings are obtained from employees and contractors Required Records 6.6

SUPPORT

Support in meeting the criteria

OneNym.id does more than assess. It also supports the client in drafting documents such as policies, AI usage rules, and incident response plans, improving configurations, training staff, and running tabletop exercises. Support ranges from providing templates to doing the work on the client's behalf. Documents produced with this support are rated Pass only where there is evidence that the client has approved them and actually operates by them, and every item that received support is identified in the AI & Cloud Security Assessment Report.

LIMITATIONS

Limitations of the Certificate

The AI & Cloud Security Assessment Certificate shows the result of checking configuration and operations within the stated scope against these criteria as of the assessment completion date. It does not guarantee that no incident will occur in the future. It is not a certification under ISO/IEC 27001, the PrivacyMark, or any other certification scheme.

Revision policy

The criteria are reviewed once a year, and changes are published on this page. Wording corrections and the addition of Recommended items (for example, v1.1) do not affect Certificates already issued. When Required items are added or changed (for example, v2.0), Certificates already issued remain valid under the previous version until they expire, and renewals are assessed against the new version.

© 2026 ReceiptRoller Inc. Reproduction, modification, or use of these criteria in another assessment scheme requires prior permission.